Edward Greenspon: The Worst Times Give Trust a Chance
Policy Speaking blogMonday March 30, 2020
Machine learning is already making a radical impact on the workplace and everyday processes. Some say learning coding is vital for all students and that the earlier they start, the better. Others ask whether we are losing sight of the values and interpersonal skills that the humanities instill. Others still wonder if AI will contribute to weakening social cohesion as, increasingly, jobs are undertaken by machines that can learn from data, identify patterns and make decisions with minimal human intervention. What does all of this mean for the roles of education institutions, training providers, businesses and policymakers? What will it take to steward digital development and support workers and the broader public as we transition to a more automated future?
PPF met with the Montréal Chapter of the Banff Forum to explore who has what roles and responsibilities to ensure the wellbeing of Canadians during and after the technological shift. Banffers made it clear: the underlying principles that we should make and follow, may make all the difference.
Concordia University in Montréal wants to capitalize on today’s wave of technological change rather than be swept away. They want to become a “next-generation university”. Dr. Guylaine Beaudry, Vice Provost of Digital Strategy and University Librarian for Concordia University gave us a behind-the-scenes look at how they’re hoping to turn the tide for their workforce and faculty, students, community and the institution of higher education.
How does a community of over 15,000 people – students, faculty, staff and more – make transformational changes all together and smoothly? Concordia’s whole of community approach is as much based in values for inclusion as it is in practicality. Beaudry explained that understanding the wide-reaching role and impact of technology on Concordia requires intentional strategies to get input from everyone, coupled with an ongoing, iterative and people-centred approach to change. “People before technology, people before technology,” Beaudry emphasised. Moving to a digital future requires not just knowing what technological adaptations are needed in the university, but also having a well-informed view of how affected people need change communicated. Listening and reflection are equally big priorities to technological adoption.
People worry about computers getting too smart and taking over the world, but the real problem is that they’re too stupid and they’ve already taken over the world – Dr. Pedro Domingos, Professor of Computer Science at the University of Washington and Author of The Master Algorithm.
AI – robotics, machine learning and big data analytics – is worth talking about, according to Renjie Butalid, Co-Founder of the Montréal AI Ethics Institute and Associate Director of the McGill Dobson Centre for Entrepreneurship. AI matters because of its scale of impact and pace of development. Unlike previous technological changes, AI innovations can upgrade existing systems and processes with unprecedented speed and scale.
Speaking from experience leading the Montréal AI Ethics Institute, which researches the ethical, safe and inclusive development of AI, Butalid emphasised the importance of starting with the right questions. We need to wonder or even worry about how the opportunities and risks of technological development will impact Canadians. Is AI technology and policy too focused on efficiency over empathy? What policies support people, workers, employers and AI collectively? How do we ensure AI develops alongside democratic visions of what is good and decent work? What AI technologies enhance human abilities like critical thinking, imagination, memory and spelling rather than outsourcing and replacing them?
While Beaudry reminded us that we can’t forget to focus on people before technology, Butalid also spoke to the importance of ensuring the people in and behind existing tech-enabled processes are visible and supported as much as creating and implementing AI in the first instance. Workers and the quality of jobs need to be supported alongside technological adoption and innovation. Butalid emphasised supporting workers basic protections and putting in new legal frameworks, regulatory changes or policy incentives where needed. Keeping a critical eye out for jobs that emerge in the new tech-enabled landscape which may be harmful to worker wellbeing (like social media platform workers reviewing explicit content for moderation) also remains a priority.
When asked who had a role in stewarding increased digitization and automation – and in providing the support to workers and jobs that comes with it – Banffers had one answer: everyone. To guide intentional and conscious strategies for digital development and cultural change, Banffers tasked everyone with upholding and designing policies along a few key principles:
The Public Policy Forum’s workshop with the Montréal chapter was the last in a series of consultations with Banff Forum members across the country on the key issues facing Canada as the world of work is changing. We heard from Banffers in Toronto, Edmonton and Vancouver and Montréal. These opportunities are part of PPF’s Inclusion to Conclusion approach to engage widely, convene practical policy conversations and generate fresh ideas.
Stay tuned! Keep up to date on our latest news and events by signing up for the Brave New Work newsletter.
For further information on the Brave New Work project, please contact Amy Davis.
The views expressed in the research papers, articles and reports reflect those of our authors and do not necessarily reflect those of our sponsors and partners.